Way more than pizza.
Yes, the NY-style and the deep dish are the headliners. But the calzones, subs, burgers, gyros, wings, pasta, and salads are why the whole table stays happy.
Bring an appetite.Pizza & CalzonesThe headliners.
Our New York style hand-tossed crust, house-made sauce, and a blend of fresh mozzarella. Five sizes: 12", 14", 16", 20", and a 24" monster.
- Big Jim's Special
Pepperoni, ham, bacon, mushrooms, onions, and green bell peppers.
12" $16.99 14" $18.99 16" $22.99 20" $29.99 24" $37.99 - Supreme Pizza
Pepperoni, ham, hamburger, Italian sausage, bacon, mushrooms, onions, and green bell peppers.
12" $18.99 14" $20.99 16" $25.99 20" $32.99 24" $39.99 - Margherita Pizza
Fresh whole-milk mozzarella slices, basil, garlic, Italian seasonings, and extra-virgin olive oil.
12" $16.99 14" $18.99 16" $22.99 20" $29.99 24" $37.99 - The Ulti-Meat Pizza
Pepperoni, ham, hamburger, Italian sausage, and bacon.
12" $16.99 14" $18.99 16" $22.99 20" $29.99 24" $37.99 - Veggie-Nator
Mushrooms, onions, green bell peppers, black olives, and green olives.
12" $16.99 14" $18.99 16" $22.99 20" $29.99 24" $37.99 - Jalapeño Popper Pizza
Cream cheese base, bacon, jalapeños, mozzarella, and cheddar.
12" $16.99 14" $18.99 16" $22.99 20" $29.99 24" $37.99 - Chicken Alfredo Pizza
House-made Alfredo sauce, chopped chicken breast, and bacon.
12" $16.99 14" $18.99 16" $22.99 20" $29.99 24" $37.99 - Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
House-made ranch base, mozzarella and cheddar, chicken, and bacon.
12" $16.99 14" $18.99 16" $22.99 20" $29.99 24" $37.99 - BBQ Chicken Pizza
BBQ sauce, mozzarella and cheddar, chicken, onions, and a BBQ drizzle.
12" $16.99 14" $18.99 16" $22.99 20" $29.99 24" $37.99 - Taco Pizza
Refried beans and house-made taco meat, lettuce, onions, olives, tomatoes, cheddar, and taco sauce on the side.
12" $16.99 14" $18.99 16" $22.99 20" $29.99 24" $37.99 - Lasagna Pizza
A classic Italian favorite meets your pizza on a thick crust.
12" $16.99 14" $18.99 16" $22.99 20" $29.99 24" $37.99 - Mac N' Cheese Pizza
Elbow macaroni in our house-made cheese sauce, topped with mozzarella and cheddar.
12" $16.99 14" $18.99 16" $22.99 20" $29.99 24" $37.99 - Chicken Fajita Pizza
Thin crust, refried beans, chicken, mozzarella, cheddar, onions, peppers, and hot sauce drizzle.
12" $16.99 14" $18.99 16" $22.99 20" $29.99 24" $37.99 - Chicken Enchilada Pizza
Sour cream base, mozzarella, cheddar, chicken, Hatch green chiles, and enchilada drizzle.
12" $16.99 14" $18.99 16" $22.99 20" $29.99 24" $37.99 - Cold Cheese Pizza
A Oneonta, NY staple — an extra layer of cold cheese on top.
12" $15.49 14" $16.99 16" $18.49 20" $22.49 24" $28.99 - Cheese Pizza
Start here and build your own.
12" $11.99 14" $12.99 16" $13.99 20" $17.99 24" $23.99 - Additional Toppings or Drizzle
Add any of our signature sauces.
12" $2.00 14" $2.25 16" $2.50 20" $3.25 24" $4.00 - Real Chicago Deep Dish
Jim brought the real thing from Chicago. Pick-up or dine-in only; please allow about an hour.
10" Cheese (feeds 2) $16.99 14" Cheese (feeds 4) $26.99 Additional toppings: 10" $2.50 · 14" $3.25
- Calzone$11.49
Fresh dough, mozzarella blend, just enough sauce, and your 2 favorite toppings — folded, baked, buttered, and topped with Parmesan.
Addt'l topping $0.75 · Make it a turnover (deep fried) $1.25
- Guido Burrito$11.49
Your choice of two toppings with house-made sauce and mozzarella, rolled in a tortilla and deep fried.
Addt'l topping $0.75
Starters & ShareablesGet the table started.
- Pesto Mozzarella Rolls$11.49
Fresh dough stuffed with mozzarella and kale pesto, rolled in cornmeal, baked golden with a garlic-butter finish.
- Breadsticks$5.49
House-made, baked with garlic and Parmesan. Comes with marinara.
- Cheese Bread$11.49
Fresh baked crust and melty cheese. Comes with marinara.
- Bone-in Wings$12.49
Breaded and deep-fried, hot sauce on the side, or tossed in a signature sauce.
- Boneless Wings$12.49
Breaded chicken breast pieces tossed in your choice of signature sauce.
- Mozzarella Sticks$11.49
Battered mozzarella fried crispy outside, stringy inside.
- Cheese Curds$11.49
Lightly beer-battered white cheddar curds. Try them with caramel.
- Mac 'n Cheese Bites$12.49
Smoked Gouda macaroni, lightly battered and golden fried.
- Corn Nuggets$11.49
Sweet creamed corn battered and golden fried.
- Mini Tacos$11.49
Mini corn tortillas filled with steak and cheese, fried. Taco sauce on the side.
- Popcorn Chicken$11.49
Popcorn-size bites of chicken.
- Pickle Fries$11.49
Corn battered and fried to a golden brown.
- Fried Mushrooms$11.49
Whole mushrooms battered and fried until crispy.
Subs, Burgers & GyrosPizza can share the stage.
- Italian Beef$15.99
Slow-roasted, thinly sliced, bathed in au jus, piled on a hoagie roll with melted mozzarella. Comes with fries or onion rings.
- Meatball Sub$12.49
Savory Italian meatballs in house-made marinara, topped with melted mozzarella.
- Chicken Parmesan$11.49
Crispy chicken, house-made marinara, melted mozzarella and Parmesan on a made-to-order bun.
- Chicken Cordon Bleu$11.49
Beer-battered chicken, brown sugar ham, and melted Swiss-American in a mayo-toasted bun.
- Chicken Sub$11.49
Grilled chicken breast, melted Swiss-American, lettuce, and tomatoes. Also available crispy.
- Bacon Sub$11.49
Our take on the BLT — chopped bacon, melted Swiss-American, lettuce, and tomatoes.
- Italian Sub$11.49
Brown sugar ham and Genoa salami, melted Swiss-American, lettuce, and tomatoes.
- Ham and Cheese$11.49
Brown sugar ham, melted Swiss-American, lettuce, and tomatoes.
- Steak and Cheese Sub$11.49
Ribeye chopped with mushrooms, grilled onions, and melted Swiss-American.
- Pizza Sub$11.49
Your choice of 3 toppings and house-made marinara, topped with melted mozzarella.
- Three Cheese BBQ Chicken Sub$11.49
Fried chicken in sweet BBQ, with Swiss-American, cheddar, and mozzarella.
- Hamburger Deluxe$13.49
Angus patty on a buttery toasted bun with lettuce, tomato, pickles, onions, and fries.
Extra patty $2.25 · Cheese/Bacon/Hatch chiles $1.50
- Pizza Burger$14.49
Angus patty smothered in marinara, 2 pizza toppings, mozzarella, on a garlic-butter bun. Fries included.
Additional toppings $1.00
- Lamb Gyro$11.49
Sliced lamb and grilled onions on a toasted pita, lettuce, tomatoes, and tzatziki.
- Chicken Gyro$11.49
Grilled chicken and grilled onions on a toasted pita, lettuce, tomatoes, and tzatziki.
Ribs, Chicken & SeafoodBeyond the pizza box.
- Wing Ding Dinner$14.49
Our famous breaded wings, bone-in or boneless, with hot sauce on the side or tossed. Comes with fries and breadsticks.
- Chicken Strip Dinner$14.49
Tender, crispy chicken strips with fries and breadsticks.
- Seafood Dinner$20.99
Beer-battered fish fillets and Panko breaded shrimp with fries and breadsticks.
- Fish Dinner$16.49
Beer-battered white fish fillets with fries and breadsticks.
- Jumbo Shrimp Dinner$17.49
Butterflied, Panko-battered jumbo shrimp, golden fried, with fries and breadsticks.
- Kane's Broke Boy$15.49
Fish fillet and Panko shrimp in Gamechanger sauce, wrapped in pita with lettuce and tomatoes. Fries or onion rings.
Pasta & SaladsA fork works, too.
- Spaghetti With Meat Sauce$11.49
Angel hair, house-made marinara with beef crumbles, and breadsticks.
Add meatballs or Italian sausage $1.50 · Tray w/ breadsticks $42.99
- Lasagna With Meat Sauce$12.49
Savory lasagna in house-made marinara, topped with mozzarella. Comes with breadsticks.
Add meatballs or Italian sausage $1.50 · Tray w/ breadsticks $42.99
- Chicken Alfredo$12.49
Linguine in house-made Alfredo, topped with grilled chicken and breadsticks.
Tray w/ breadsticks $46.99
- Tossed Salad
Fresh lettuce, pepperoncinis, olives, Roma tomatoes, breadsticks, and your choice of dressing.
Small $8.49 Large $10.49 Tray w/ breadsticks $35.99
- Chicken Salad
Grilled or crispy chicken and cheddar over the tossed salad.
Small $9.49 Large $12.99 Tray w/ breadsticks $41.99
- Greek Salad
Feta crumbles and sliced beets over the tossed salad.
Small $9.49 Large $13.99 Tray w/ breadsticks $41.99
- Antipasto Salad
Ham, Genoa salami, and mozzarella over the tossed salad.
Small $10.49 Large $13.99 Tray w/ breadsticks $41.99
- Taco Salad$14.49
Fried flour tortilla packed with lettuce, onions, olives, tomatoes, cheddar, and taco meat, with beans and salsa. Add guac/sour cream extra.
SidesRoom for a little extra.
- Fries$4.49
Our signature fries, coated and fried until golden and crispy.
- Onion Rings$4.99
Battered and fried until golden and crispy.
DessertsSave a little room.
- Cinnamon Bread$8.99
Crust buttered, coated with brown sugar and cinnamon, baked golden, with caramel and vanilla icing for dipping.
- Oreo Pizza$9.99
Buttered crust baked golden, vanilla icing, crumbled Oreos, and a chocolate syrup drizzle.
- Whole Cheesecake$27.99
Creamy New York style cheesecake.
Add chocolate, caramel, or cherries $6.50
- Cheesecake Slice$6.99
A slice with your choice of chocolate, caramel, or cherry topping.
- Cannolis$6.99
Delicate shells stuffed with chocolate chip cream and a chocolate drizzle.
- Funnel Cake Sticks$11.99
Fair-food favorite in bite-size sticks, with powdered sugar and chocolate. Shareable.
Kids Menu / 12 & UnderLittle appetites. Still Big Jim's.
- Kid's Pizza$6.99
Kid-size pizza with 1 topping: cheese, pepperoni, hamburger, Italian sausage, or bacon.
- Spaghetti With Meat Sauce$6.99
Spaghetti with house-made meat marinara and a breadstick.
- Chicken Bits$6.99
Popcorn chicken with fries and a dipping sauce — ranch, ketchup, mustard, or BBQ.
- Mac N' Cheese$6.99
Kid-size bowl of elbow macaroni in house-made cheese sauce with mozzarella and cheddar.
Does Big Jim's have more than pizza?
A lot more. Burgers, gyros, calzones, subs, wings, pasta, salads, and seafood.
Is there a kids menu?
Yes. Jump to the Kids Menu section above to explore that part of the menu.
Any gluten-free or food-sensitivity options?
Yes, a full section. See our Gluten-Free page.